Opposition spokesman on Health Dr.  Alfred Dawes looks at the Repairs to the Cornwall Regional Hospital in  Montego Bay, St. James
Opposition spokesman on Health Dr. Alfred Dawes looks at the Repairs to the Cornwall Regional Hospital in Montego Bay, St. James

More than a week after the Prime Minister declared it open, western Jamaica’s flagship emergency department had yet to receive the public — and the Opposition says nobody properly told the people.

MONTEGO BAY, Jamaica, November 22, 2026 — The ribbon has been cut, the speeches delivered, the photographs posted. What Cornwall Regional Hospital’s new Accident and Emergency Department had not done, by the Government’s own account this week, is treat the public.

That gap — between a ceremony and a service — is at the centre of a sharp row between Opposition Spokesman on Health and Wellness Dr. Alfred Dawes and Health and Wellness Minister Dr. Christopher Tufton. It leaves western Jamaica asking a simple question: where, exactly, should a sick person go?

Prime Minister Dr. Andrew Holness officially reopened the department on Friday, November 13, apologising to the people of the west for the prolonged delay in the hospital’s $23.5-billion rehabilitation. Four days later, Dawes called on the Ministry to issue an immediate public advisory telling Jamaicans that the new department is not yet functional, and that patients should keep seeking care at other facilities until further notice.

“The ribbon was cut. The doors are not open.” — Dr. Alfred Dawes

“Patients from across Western Jamaica heard there’s a new A&E and came in good faith, expecting care,” Dawes said. “Instead they are crowding into the same cramped space that was already over capacity. The new building cannot treat them yet, and the old one cannot hold them.”

‘The person who can’t wait’

Dawes, a surgeon by profession, framed the matter as one of patient safety rather than point-scoring.

“An emergency room has to keep space for the person who can’t wait: the heart attack, the stroke, the child who can’t breathe, the road crash victim,” he said. “Every unnecessary arrival pushes them further back in the line. Our doctors and nurses are already stretched, and now they are managing a crowd the system invited but then failed to warn.”

His remedy, he argued, costs nothing. “Tell the people the truth. Say clearly which facilities are open and where they should go, and remind them that no one in a genuine emergency will be turned away. Then give a firm date for when the new department will actually receive patients. This is basic responsibility, not politics.”

He also wants the Minister to explain why the facility was opened before it was ready to function.

Tufton: ‘Irresponsible and mischievous’

The Minister was not amused. According to The Gleaner, Tufton branded Dawes “irresponsible and mischievous,” insisting the Government had been clear from the outset that a short handover would follow the ceremony to allow for deep cleaning and the relocation of staff. Those arrangements, he said, were outlined at the launch, which Opposition representatives attended. Dawes was not among them.

On the mechanics, Tufton has a point. No responsible health system moves emergency medicine into a new building overnight. Clinical Coordinator Dr. Delroy Fray told the Jamaica Observer that the department needs a further deep clean and swabbing, and that staff need a few days to master the new equipment.

But on the question Dawes actually asked, the answers do not line up. The Minister’s statement, as quoted by the Observer, said the facility is “expected to become accessible to the public next week.” Fray’s estimate was about two weeks. One is a politician’s calendar, the other a clinician’s — and neither is a firm date.

The view from the waiting area

Outside the hospital, the Observer found opinion divided. One man said his brother, hurt in a motorcycle crash, had no bed and was lying across two chairs; after years of waiting, he saw no reason to wait longer. Another, bringing food for a relative, was content to let the work be finished properly.

Both reactions are reasonable. So is the confusion. When a Prime Minister cuts a ribbon and the Ministry’s own channels announce a department “officially opened,” ordinary people do not parse the fine print of a transition period explained from a podium. They hear “open,” and they come.

Fray noted that the Mount Salem Health Centre remains available, and that the new unit is meant for serious emergencies — major trauma, strokes, heart attacks, crash and gunshot victims. That is precisely the guidance that belongs in a clear, widely broadcast advisory, not buried in the crossfire of a political quarrel.

A long wait, a short fuse

History sharpens the frustration. Cornwall Regional, the west’s Type A hospital, opened in 1974 and has been under rehabilitation since noxious fumes drove services out of the main building nearly a decade ago. As recently as May, the Ministry was telling the country the A&E would open by the middle of 2026. In July, Dawes said the project had missed its target for a seventh time. The rest of the hospital is not expected to open before March 2027.

“The people of the West have waited 8 years for Cornwall Regional to be restored,” Dawes said. “They deserve a hospital that works, not another photo opportunity.”

The new department is, by the Ministry’s description, a serious facility — twice the size of the old space, with operating theatres and observation beds. Nobody in the west wants it to fail. But a hospital is measured by the patients it treats, not the ribbons it cuts. Until those doors actually open, the least the Ministry owes the public is a date, directions, and the plain truth.

— 30 —

Image